Yahoo Answers is shutting down on 4 May 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.
Can you be a Libertarian and Support Socialized Medicine?
Mike Gravel claims he is no longer a Democrat and the is now a Libertarian. His platform on his website states clearly that he is in support of "universal healthcare system that provides equal medical services to all citizens" at government expense.
How can you be in the party of individual liberty and support government control over your health?
(I like him better than the other Democrats but that's not saying much)
9 Answers
- Anonymous1 decade agoFavourite answer
Mike Gravel is not who comes to mind when I hear libertarian as libertarians are almost the complete opposite of socialists. He is a liberal posing as a libertarian.
- justgoodfolkLv 71 decade ago
I don't understand what got into him. I believe the answer is no. I'm a Democratic socialist and a few months ago I scored no differences with Mike Gravel in a test, now he's running for the libertarians, the party of the free market cures all, a notion I strongly reject. Some sources suggest he changed positions and actually moved but it stays weird and certainly if his campaign website still carries the old positions.
"Perhaps the most breath-taking u-turn in the primaries so far belongs to Mike Gravel, a left-leaning Democrat and undoubted civil libertarian who has now put his lot in with the Libertarian Party. On the social scale this doesn't represent much of a leap, but economically the mercurial Mr.Gravel, a long-standing champion of universal health care and a redistributive economy, has vaulted from social democracy to a radical neo-liberal platform well to the right of most Republicans. "
- 1 decade ago
A Libertarian that believes in that issue is moving toward socialism. Come on over the rest of the way now!
- ideogeneticLv 71 decade ago
That's a good question.
Maybe Libertarianism is maturing and admitting that there are market failures. However, I'm not sure how they can do that without discrediting their market fundamentalism in toto. In the areas where the market can't be the solution, it would be unethical to continue to rely on it, so I admire Gravel for that.
Gravel could be the vanguard of a wiser quasi-Libertarianism.
By the way, you have no individual liberty if you have no life. Life is the foundation of individual liberty. Gravel has recognized that. Classical Libertarians are still unaware of that fundamental logic.
- LaissezFaireLv 61 decade ago
No, you cannot. I asked that question too "WTF is Mike Gravel doing running as a libertarian when he's clearly a liberal?"....
Anyways, no, libertarians don't generally support a universal healthcare system. It would cost too much and simply put: It's not fair to steal from one person to give to another...
Ron Paul is a good example of a libertarian.
- T-BoneLv 71 decade ago
To answer your question;
No, going from a Democrat to a Libertarian is like going from a Anarchist to a Christian. I would not believe him.