Could your country's All time XI beat the West Indies 2nd XI? ... mine couldn't?

Question

Here's my selection from the players that didn't make their cricinfo all time XI:

Desmond Haynes
Roy Fredericks
Frank Worrell
Everton Weekes
Clyde Walcott
Collie Smith
Jeffrey Dujon
Joel Garner
Andy Roberts
Colin Croft
Alfred Valentine

That includes the 3 Ws - who are considered the best middle order to have ever played the game!  And I've still left out Kanhai, Rowe, Lloyd and Richardson in the middle order and Hall, Walsh & Bishop in the fast bowling ranks!

2nd question:  Do you agree with my selection?

For the first XI: http://www.cricinfo.com/magazine/content/story/468845.html

hammerman · Accepted Answer

My guess about Gibbs being selected came true.
The team I support i.e. South Africa,will be able to beat this team.

PLZ.answer this.........http://au.answers.yahoo.com/question/index;_ylt=AlO4bJIOAPLtiFWB_APpbhjg5gt.;_ylv=3?qid=20100729035039AA3jgYl

Anonymous · Answer

I agree with your selection but I don't trust upon the rankings by cricinfo or wisden or for that matter any reputed organization because they are made my a team of individuals and they are prone to jealousy and hatred. Make ur own and be happy.stick with that whatever the world says.

? · Answer

yes, SA all time 11 can maybe beat the WIxi  choosen by you, but the one choosen by cricinfo, no ways.

Could your country's All time XI beat the West Indies 2nd XI? ... mine couldn't?

3 Answers