Yahoo Answers is shutting down on 4 May 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

sami
Lv 5
sami asked in Society & CultureHolidaysRamadan · 1 decade ago

do shia know if they were born out of nikah or mutaa?

do they ever ask they mothers?

just wounding. since they all seem to acknowledge that mutaa is halal.

Update:

i meant do shia ask their mothers? would they accept mutaa marriage for their sisters or daughters?

Update 2:

@Ali M

and why are you getting angry? im just asking !

Update 3:

@Ali M

yes, whatever you claim about abu haneefah only proves that he never said it is halal or permissible, he just said that he doesn't know of the correct punishment for that stuff based on the seerah of the Prophet and his companions, so i dont see what are you trying to prove here?

Update 4:

@shiite muslim

no way dude, your not Muslim, duuh

Update 5:

@shiite muslim

yes, i know that according to your little sectioned religion you can marry for short periods of times, but unfortunately for you that's not permissible in Islam.

Update 6:

@Ali M

alright, so go ahead then, ask your mother, and be nice to share with us "the good" news, well be right here waiting ;)

Update 7:

@Pro Active

really? how touching. im almost crying... especially coming from someone who curses the Prophet companions...

Update 8:

@Pro Active

yesh sure now its just yazid, just tell me one thing, is it really you talking or is it taqyyiah?

Update 9:

@shadow3d..

yes i would ask if i knew that my religion allowed mutaa=zina to be practiced.

Update 10:

@shiite muslim

bla bla brother mother sister father bla bla... that's all i got from you

you wrote about 20 lines to say nothing. are you gonna answer any soon?

9 Answers

Relevance
  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago
    Favourite answer

    my brothers and sisters if you all call yourself as muslims whether shia or sunni whatever you should not talk like this.these are not the teachings of our beloved prophet and the holy Quran.no matter from what sect we belong we should study Quran and hadith and sunnah of prophet Muhammad for even a single issue and surely we can find our solution.and we can,t find it here by posting a question and get the answer by an illetrate person. and just fall into a fight and dispute.Allah Bless all the Muslims

    Source(s): A Proud Muslim
  • Pro Active
    1 decade ago

    you call this ahul sunnah? this is what our Prophet taught us?

    surely you are from the Ahul Fitna

    cursing sahaba??? we dont consider yazid or his pops a sahaba, just like how you dont consider the Ahlul bayt are Imams

    u got that?, no go be a good little fitna spreader, and lie some more ok?

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Mutah is a form of nikah and is halal so we cannot have any problem with it. Do you ask your mother if you are a child of zina?

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Well done Ali. Busted again Nasabi.

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    do u know we muslems must keep unity

  • Anonymous
    1 decade ago

    Born from Nikkah, Muta, Pre-Marital sex, who cares, a life is a life, and life is precious !i

  • Serenity
    Lv 5
    1 decade ago

    Yep you are "wounding" the hearts of some maybe...I suggest that you should stop trying create controversy.

  • FaRaZ KhUwAjA
    Lv 6
    1 decade ago

    Most of the shia i know do not know who their Biological father is !

    So i can only say that Most of them Do not know If they are The Output of Muta or NIkah !

  • یا حسین Shi'e Muslim
    Lv 5
    1 decade ago

    Can i have Family bond with your sister mother and your wife??

    Your salafie and wahabies have given a fatwa so can i ?

    And i think your just like mawiyah.

    He had 4 father how many you have dont hide be honest....

    @ Asker

    If iam a muslim or not i want to have A LOVELLY family bond With them....Muahhhhhhhhhhh

    @Asker

    How many New Brother You have ?

    If i Try to have family bond with your family What i will be to you

    With your mom Your ................................................... brother

    With your sister Your ................................................... ?

    WHat about your wife .................................................... ?

    @asker

    Should i delete my Answer ?

    Dont cry

    Alhumdulilah iam a Muslim BUT BUT

    I dont want to have family bond With you kaffir wahabies.

    i just want to have a time pass....

    Hey dude Name your New Brothers

    Ask your mom She will tell you

    Inform me ok

    ............................................................ Waiting....Dont Forget

Still have questions? Get answers by asking now.