Yahoo Answers is shutting down on 4 May 2021 (Eastern Time) and the Yahoo Answers website is now in read-only mode. There will be no changes to other Yahoo properties or services, or your Yahoo account. You can find more information about the Yahoo Answers shutdown and how to download your data on this help page.

?
Lv 7
? asked in Consumer ElectronicsHome Theater · 8 years ago

What makes you qualified to answer questions on home theater?

I often see people giving advice on home theater or music systems that are completely wrong or is just really poor advice. There should be a section in this forum that gives a persons qualifications so people can be assured they are getting good advice. I'm curious what makes you think you are a expert and should be giving advice to others? What schooling or books have you used and give a synopsis of your philosophy on what makes a good sounding system and what to look for in speakers and equipment. I have been designing high end audio video systems for of 40 years now and have designed using some of the very finest in home audio video equipment. What's your background ?

Kevin

Update:

Edit: Yes I will be going to the Newport Audio show Friday for sure, maybe and hopefully Saturday. Would be happy to meet you on Saturday if I go. Email me and I'll give you my phono number.

Kevin

Update 2:

Edit: Love your answer Alan, and would agree with you on vintage gear, its all built like a tank. I also think that much of the vintage gear was more concerned about sound quality then all these features that actually degrade sound. The parts quality of todays receivers is really pretty poor in comparison that is why I recommend integrated amplifiers as they use better parts typically which results in better sound of course.

8 Answers

Relevance
  • Exact
    Lv 4
    8 years ago
    Favourite answer

    I rarely ever ask or answer here anymore, I've moved on to forum's. Forum's definitely have more knowledge about home audio but I ask here sometimes because there are exceptions like you, A/V Daddy, Grumpy Mac and a few others.

    I answer the questions I know can answer. I've been a big denthusiast for the past 10 years and know more than the average person. But I've also recently switched from home theater (multiple channels) to only 2 channels (stereo) because I listen to music way more often. I guess one day I can have both in separate rooms!

    Anyone going to the Newport Show??

  • 8 years ago

    I myself am an Independent Custom Home Theater Installer. I've been doing it for about 10 years now but way before that I was already involved in audio and video as an enthusiast. I spend hours and hours installing, testing, troubleshooting and designing media rooms from scratch - sticking to the standards. I also spend a lot of time inside attics, running cables through walls, ceilings, basements and any other space with a possibility and I'm constantly explaining to customers the pros and cons of different technologies. I've also worked for other companies locally and I've had the experience to work with different people. Some of them good, some of them not much. I've known people that claim 20 or 30 years of experience and for some reason occasionally they get a little impressed on how I approach problems and the knowledge I have for my "short period of time". During the time that I've been doing this, I've learned that experience is indeed very important but it isn't all. When you love something and you're open to every aspect of it, you can absorb much more in a short period of time than when you do it out of pure necessity. And yes, HOME THEATER is full of opinions, theories, methods and possibilities. No two installers will think the same - everyone will have a different point of view but at the end of the day, the point is achieving the best possible install and get the most out of every system without copromising anyone or anything. So that's basically my background and yes, we obviously have other people here (@ YAHOO Answers) giving their inexperienced opinions or inconsistent conclusions. But that shouldn't bother us as long as we try our best to help others. People by nature should follow logic, knowledge and good judgement - good day.

  • ?
    Lv 7
    8 years ago

    I remember the previous generation of surround sound, but we called it "quadraphonic" back then!

    I've repaired audio equipment since the "vintage" audio of today was a new product. I am also an audiophile, although I don't have the high-end equipment I used to. Being semi-retired, I enjoy restoring older equipment, and younger people have gained an appreciation for the quality that was the norm back in the 1960's and 1970's.

    So once in a while, for a change of pace, I stop in around these parts and answer a few questions. Nice break from the rows of receivers and the like I have waiting to be repaired and restored. I have found a strong niche market in Magnavox Astro-Sonic console stereos from the 1960's. They always need recapped, but being very early solid state, they were over-built to the extreme. They never have a transistor failure. Given the state of audio reproduction equipment back in that era, and the poor quality of source material, they had a very musical sonic coloration that created a pleasing musical presentation. I can't rebuild them fast enough, and they do take time. Times sure have changed, haven't they?

  • 8 years ago

    Lets see...

    BSEE from Berkeley.

    A love of movies and theater but with wife/kids/dogs - I do not get a chance to go to the movies as often as I like. So I started studying Home Theater back in the ProLogic days.

    A company I worked with were early adopters of the AC2 compression codex made by Dolby Labs. This was the 2-channel version of what became AC3 - the codex behind Dolby Digital 5.1. There were 'issues' and since we were in San Francisco and Dolby Labs was based in SF - the engineers used to show up to take samples of problems we discovered. I learned a lot about digital encoding from these guys. I also worked with sound engineers who taught me a lot of the issues and 'tricks' used in modern sound studios.

    I became an administrator at Home Theater Forum and worked the Basics area for years. I taught people how to hook things up, calibrate their sound systems, learned about RTA, burned my own test CD disk to map my room response, studied the Hass Effect and psycho acoustics, etc.

    I have also studied the "junk science" behind expensive copper that promise to reduce judder and the 'secret' winding that promise to "temporally align" the signals caused by digital recordings. I laugh, then cry at the 1 meter "Digital Cable" advertised for $800 in the audiophile magazines. I studied coax, the white papers at the Belden Cable site and learned to make my own HD compatible RCA cables.

    I've been doing this for about 20 years. I am not a 'professional' in that I do not charge for my help when I install, calibrate or advise people how to hook up and operate their gear. I am an engineer - I can understand the theory behind the way things work.

  • 8 years ago

    My only question was about the best way to clean the inside of an old stereo receiver. I have a little experience with 70's and 80's equipment with systems that I bought but none concerning repairing or real cleaning. I have an old Akai AA-R20, a Modular Component Systems 3253 and a Marantz SR 3100. All three need cleaning but the Marantz started smoking from a capacitor when I plugged it in. I bought it and the MCS on E-Bay.

    Anyt thoughts about these receivers as to good or bad? I would like to know what you think about them.

    Thanks.

    Urbane

  • lanman
    Lv 4
    5 years ago

    howdy, i might assume right here traits in a solid nurse: ? staying power - its the appropriate feeling understanding that somebody else cares once you're in discomfort. ? solid experience of humour - lightens the temper and cheers you up whilst situations are undesirable. ? well mannered - manners are in simple terms spectacular. ? Sympathy - Be sympathetic yet do no longer stay on the project. ? chuffed - seeing somebody else chuffed will make you chuffed too. ? Conversational - some human beings want to understand there is somebody you could constantly communicate with once you're down. i might want to determine nurses who're constantly chuffed and have a grin on their face whilst doing their activity. I understand its very complicated and tiring artwork, yet a grin costs no longer something. luckily, i've got basically even been into well being center as quickly as, as quickly as I chop up my head open whilst i became 6 years previous. by way of gentle concussion, i do no longer keep in mind plenty, however the nurses did no longer cheer me up :( additionally, i think of its incredibly admirable of you to be a nurse and help a number of those human beings. properly achieved! it incredibly is the same occupation i desire too! The delight of helping others would desire to be incredible! X

  • 8 years ago

    30 years professional AV experience, including sales, consultation, design & installation of home theater systems.

  • 8 years ago

    Usually if someone's wrong, somebody else corrects them.

Still have questions? Get answers by asking now.